CapCenter

Shopping your policy at renewal

Your insurance renewal is the easiest time to compare prices, because switching then usually avoids cancellation fees and gaps. Here is how to review what you have now, compare quotes fairly, keep your mortgage servicer in the loop and decide whether to stay or switch.

Key takeaways

  • Renewal is usually the simplest time to switch, with no mid-term cancellation to manage.
  • Compare quotes with the same coverage limits and deductibles, or the prices won't mean much.
  • Ask your current carrier about discounts and updated home details before you decide.
  • If your insurance is paid through escrow, tell your mortgage servicer when you switch.

Next step: Get a homeowners insurance quote

Why renewal is the time to shop

Your renewal notice usually arrives a few weeks before the policy ends. It shows your new premium, and sometimes changes to coverage. That window gives you time to compare without rushing.

Switching at renewal means your old policy simply ends and the new one begins. You avoid cancelling partway through the term, which can come with fees or a refund that takes time.

Review what you have now

Start with your declarations page. It lists your coverage limits, deductibles, endorsements and discounts.

Check whether your dwelling coverage still fits what it would cost to rebuild your home today. Building costs change, and an old limit may leave you short after a big loss.

Update your home's details

Carriers price policies on what they know about your home. If you replaced the roof, updated the electrical or plumbing, or added a security system, tell them. Those updates may lower your premium.

Also share changes that add risk, like a new pool or a home business. Leaving them out could cause problems at claim time.

Compare quotes fairly

  • Use the same dwelling, liability and personal property limits
  • Match deductibles, including any separate wind or hail deductible
  • Include the same endorsements, such as water backup
  • Ask about discounts for bundling, claims-free history and protective devices
  • Look at the carrier's claims service, not just the price

Switching without a gap

Set your new policy to start on the day the old one ends, so you are never without coverage. Then tell your current carrier you won't renew.

If you have a mortgage, your lender requires coverage. When your premium is paid from escrow, send the new policy details to your mortgage servicer so they pay the right carrier.

How CapCenter's insurance agency can help

CapCenter's insurance agency has licensed agents who compare quotes from multiple carriers for home, condo, renters and auto coverage. Bundling home and auto usually earns a multi-policy discount.

We review your policy each renewal to make sure you are not paying too much for your insurance. You don't need a CapCenter mortgage to get a quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a fee to switch at renewal?

Usually not. Because the old policy simply ends, there's typically nothing to cancel. Switching mid-term may come with a fee, depending on the carrier.

Will I lose loyalty discounts if I switch?

Possibly. Compare the total price of the new policy with your renewal price, after all discounts, before you decide.

When should I start shopping?

When your renewal notice arrives, often a few weeks before the policy ends. That gives you time to compare and set up the new policy without a gap.

Do I need to tell my mortgage company?

Yes, if your insurance is paid through escrow. Send the new policy details to your mortgage servicer so they pay the new carrier.

Will shopping for quotes affect my credit?

Many carriers use an insurance score when they quote, and these checks generally don't affect your credit score the way a loan application can. Ask the agent if you're unsure.

Can I get a quote without a CapCenter mortgage?

Yes. Anyone can get a quote from CapCenter's insurance agency.

For general information only. Coverage depends on your policy, carrier and state. Insurance offered through CapCenter’s insurance agency.

Get a free quote

Capping costs since 1997.