CapCenter

When refinancing doesn’t make sense

A lower rate isn't automatically a better deal. Here are the situations where refinancing can cost more than it saves, and how ZERO Closing Costs changes the math.

Key takeaways

  • Restarting a long term can add total interest, even at a lower rate.
  • With typical lender fees, moving before your break-even point can mean the refinance cost you money.
  • Check your current loan for a prepayment penalty before you refinance.
  • A drop in credit or harder-to-document income can mean you won't get a better rate.
  • With ZERO Closing Costs, the fee question mostly goes away, but term and total interest still matter.

Next step: See how much refinancing could save you

You'd restart a loan that's mostly paid down

Say you're 15 years into a 30-year loan. A new 30-year loan can lower your payment, but it also spreads your balance over 30 more years. You could pay more interest in total, even at a lower rate.

If you want a lower rate without restarting the clock, ask about a shorter term, like 20 or 15 years. You can also keep the new 30-year loan and pay extra each month to stay on your old payoff date.

You'll move before you break even

Most refinances with closing costs take time to pay off. Your break-even point is your closing costs divided by your monthly savings. If you sell or refinance again before then, the fees cost more than you saved.

With CapCenter's ZERO Closing Costs, CapCenter pays for or waives the closing costs typically charged to process the loan (restrictions apply). That leaves little or nothing to earn back. You still pay prepaid interest and fund escrow, but those aren't fees. They're costs you'd have either way.

Your loan has a prepayment penalty

Some loans charge a fee if you pay them off early. Many common home loans don't, but it's worth checking. Look at your promissory note or ask your servicer. If there is a penalty, add it to your costs when you compare.

Your credit or income has changed

Your new rate depends on your credit, income, debts and home value today, not when you first bought. If your credit score has dropped, your debts have grown, or your income is harder to document, you may not qualify for a better rate than you have now. It may make sense to wait and improve those first.

Your rate is already close to today's rates

If today's rates are about the same as yours, a refinance may not lower your payment much. With typical fees, a small drop often isn't worth it. With ZERO Closing Costs, even a small drop can still save you money, as long as you're comfortable with the new term.

You'd use cash-out for everyday spending

A cash-out refinance turns home equity into cash and makes your mortgage bigger. That debt is secured by your home. Cash-out tends to work best for things with lasting value, like repairs or paying off high-rate debt with a plan to stay out of it. If you like your current rate, a home equity loan lets you borrow against your equity and keep your first mortgage.

A quick check before you refinance

Answer these with your loan consultant before you lock.

  • How long do you expect to keep the home and the loan?
  • What are the total closing costs, if any, and your monthly savings?
  • How many years are left on your current loan, and what term are you choosing?
  • Will you pay more or less total interest over the time you'll keep the loan?
  • Does your current loan have a prepayment penalty?

Frequently asked questions

Is it ever worth refinancing to a higher rate?

Sometimes, for example to take cash out or to remove a borrower from the loan. If you only need cash and like your current rate, compare a home equity loan.

What is a prepayment penalty?

A fee some loans charge if you pay off the loan early. Your note will say whether yours has one.

Is a small rate drop worth it?

With typical closing costs, a small drop often isn't. With ZERO Closing Costs, a lower payment can come out ahead sooner. Compare the term and total interest too.

What if I plan to move in a year or two?

With closing costs to recover, a refinance may not pay off. With ZERO Closing Costs, there's much less to earn back, so it can still make sense.

Does refinancing hurt my credit?

Applying usually causes a credit inquiry, which can lower your score a little for a short time. Your loan consultant can explain what to expect.

Can I lower my rate without restarting at 30 years?

Yes. You can choose a shorter term, or keep a 30-year loan and make extra principal payments.

For general information only. Program rules and limits vary. Not a commitment to lend. NMLS ID #67717.

See your refinance savings

Capping costs since 1997.