CapCenter

Selling when you owe more than it’s worth

When you owe more on your mortgage than your home would sell for, you're underwater. You can still sell, but you'll need a plan for the shortfall. Here is how to find your numbers, the options you have, how a short sale works, and what it can mean for your credit and taxes.

Key takeaways

  • Start with two numbers: your loan payoff and a realistic estimate of what the home would sell for.
  • You can cover the gap with cash, wait and pay down the loan, rent the home, or ask your lender about a short sale.
  • A short sale needs lender approval, takes longer than a regular sale and can affect your credit.
  • Talk with your lender early, before you miss payments, to keep the most options open.

Next step: See what your home is worth

Get your numbers first

Request a payoff statement from your mortgage servicer. It shows exactly what you would owe on a given date, which is often a little more than your balance.

Then get a value estimate based on recent nearby sales. Subtract selling costs, such as agent fees and transfer taxes, to see what you would really net.

A shortfall example

Hypothetical example. Say your payoff is $310,000 and your home would likely sell for $300,000. If selling costs come to about $18,000, you would net about $282,000. That leaves a shortfall of about $28,000 to cover before the sale can close.

Your options

  • Bring cash to closing to cover the shortfall
  • Wait, keep paying and let the balance come down
  • Rent the home until values or your equity improve
  • Ask your lender about a loan modification if the real problem is the payment
  • Ask your lender about a short sale if you must sell and can't cover the gap

How a short sale works

In a short sale, your lender agrees to accept less than you owe. You usually need to show a hardship, such as a job loss, and share financial documents.

Short sales take longer than regular sales because the lender must approve the offer. They can affect your credit, though usually less than a foreclosure does.

Will you still owe the difference?

Not necessarily. It depends on your lender's approval letter and the rules where you live. Some lenders waive the rest of the debt, and some keep the right to collect it.

Read the approval carefully before you sign. An attorney can explain what it means for you.

Taxes and buying again later

Forgiven mortgage debt can sometimes count as taxable income, and some exceptions may apply. A tax professional can tell you how it affects your return.

You can buy again after a short sale. Most loan programs set a waiting period, and the length depends on the program. You need a credit score of at least 620 for a CapCenter loan.

Frequently asked questions

Will a short sale hurt my credit?

It can. A short sale usually shows on your credit report and can lower your score, though often less than a foreclosure. On-time payments afterward help you rebuild.

Is forgiven debt taxed?

It can be. Forgiven debt is sometimes treated as income, with some exceptions. Talk with a tax professional about your situation.

Will I owe the difference after a short sale?

It depends on your lender's agreement and the rules where you live. Read the approval letter carefully and ask an attorney if it's unclear.

Can I buy again after a short sale?

Yes, usually after a waiting period. The length depends on the loan program, so ask a loan consultant when you might qualify.

Can I sell an underwater home without a short sale?

Yes, if you can bring cash to closing to cover the shortfall. The sale then works like any other.

When should I call my lender?

As early as you can, ideally before you miss a payment. Lenders usually have more options for borrowers who reach out early.

For general information only. Not tax or legal advice. CapCenter realty services in VA, NC, MD & DC.

Get your home’s value

Capping costs since 1997.